Evaluating a scientific argument
Evaluate the argument “The window plants grew taller, so light accounts for the entire difference.” Have students propose an observation that would support one explanation more strongly than another.
Edit templateClassroom use
What should I prepare, and how should I review the result?
Prepare these materials or details: Claim, data table, grade band. Finish by discussing the prompt “What observation could distinguish two explanations?”
How to use this template
1. Gather the materials
Before using this template, gather the following: Claim, data table, grade band.
2. Assign the worksheet
Evaluate the argument “The window plants grew taller, so light accounts for the entire difference.” Leave the response cells blank when printing for students.
3. Review the result
Use the follow-up prompt to review the work. The completed template can capture Supporting evidence, alternative explanation, evidence to collect.
Frequently asked questions
Where is my draft saved?
Reopen this template in the same browser on the same device to continue editing. Save a PDF before clearing browser data or starting another copy.
Can I print a blank form?
Yes. Leave the fields blank and select Print / Save PDF. If you have a draft, save a copy before clearing its entries.
Related classroom templates
Experiment variables planner
Compare how different folds affect the load a paper bridge can carry. First identify the one condition you will change.
Experimental data log
Drop a ball from the same height three times and measure its bounce height. Include units and conditions.
Evidence for a scientific conclusion
A flat paper bridge held 3, 4 and 3 coins. A folded bridge held 8, 7 and 8. Which carried more in these tests?