Historical source credibility check
Examine a report and a diary about the same event. Identify the authors, dates and audiences, then cross-check one shared claim. Mark the claim that needs independent support before asking students to locate a third source.
Edit templateClassroom use
What should I prepare, and how should I review the result?
Fictional classroom sources. A: An April 8 school newspaper report says three classes attended Friday's reading club in the assembly hall. B: An April 8 student diary says a book discussion was underway when the writer's class arrived on Friday; the writer heard only the second half. Finish by discussing the prompt “Which question requires a third source?”
How to use this template
1. Gather the materials
Before using this template, gather the following: Sources, background, inquiry question.
2. Assign the worksheet
Examine a report and a diary about the same event. Identify the authors, dates and audiences, then cross-check one shared claim. Leave the response cells blank when printing for students.
3. Review the result
Use the follow-up prompt to review the work. The completed template can capture Author and audience, perspective, corroboration, limitations.
Teacher reference
Worked classroom example
Materials Grade 8 history. The teacher supplies a dated newspaper excerpt and a dated private diary about the same event.
Task Identify the author or byline, date and intended reader for each source. Select one shared statement and locate evidence in both.
Suggested responses Shared statement ____. Newspaper quotation ____. Diary quotation ____. A question neither answers ____. A further source to seek ____.
Teacher notes Identify checkable sources in the teacher copy. Discuss source independence and what each writer could observe firsthand.
Teaching notes
Use these fictional sources to practice identifying authors, audiences and corroboration. Ask students to mark the part of the event the diarist did not see.
Frequently asked questions
Where is my draft saved?
Reopen this template in the same browser on the same device to continue editing. Save a PDF before clearing browser data or starting another copy.
Can I print a blank form?
Yes. Leave the fields blank and select Print / Save PDF. If you have a draft, save a copy before clearing its entries.
Related classroom templates
Historical cause-and-effect chain
Arrange events chronologically, then use evidence to distinguish sequence from causation.
One event, multiple perspectives
Write two short accounts of the same event from different perspectives. Use the same verified facts.
Map evidence analysis
Compare two dated maps. Read their legends and scales before drawing spatial inferences.