Scoring consistency check
Start with the samples where scores differ most. Compare reasoning on the same criterion. Rescore a sample that produced disagreement to see whether the clarified rule brings the two judgments together.
Edit templateClassroom use
Which details should I check before printing?
Review “Sample and criterion”, “Scores and rationales” and “Review decision” and leave any student response areas open for handwriting.
How to use this template
1. Gather the materials
Before using this template, gather the following: Item, rubric, two anonymous scores.
2. Complete the working notes
Start with the samples where scores differ most. Compare reasoning on the same criterion.
3. Review the result
Use the follow-up prompt to review the work. The completed template can capture Causes of disagreement, samples to revisit, agreed rules.
Frequently asked questions
Where is my draft saved?
Reopen this template in the same browser on the same device to continue editing. Save a PDF before clearing browser data or starting another copy.
Can I print a blank form?
Yes. Leave the fields blank and select Print / Save PDF. If you have a draft, save a copy before clearing its entries.
Related classroom templates
Classroom exit ticket
A quick check-in to see what clicked and what needs another look.
Student learning observation record
Record specific classroom observations and plan the next step in student support.
Assessment blueprint
Allocate questions and points, then check that every objective has corresponding evidence.